Document Type : Research Paper
Author
PhD Candidate of Political Sociology, Razi University, Kermanshah, Iran
Abstract
Iranian sentiments and the development and backwardness are the focus of the upcoming article. According to the general belief and what is generally believed and shown, especially in scientific products, the Iranian sentiments as an independent variable has negative characteristics that are always a roadblock in the path of various types of development, and this has gone so far that it is recognized as an assumption. This is the fact that many assumption breaking elements can be presented. On this basis, the basic question of this research is that what the position between "Iranian sentiments" in the issue of "Development" is? To answer this question; we used a three-level model. The first level deals with the effects of sentiments on development. The second level uses 10 assumption-breaking items to pose question about Iranian sentiments as an independent variable, and the third level advances institutionalism as a level of integration, where Iranian sentiments are classified into the dependent variable of development. In the end, this article concludes that Iranian sentiments do not have an essential influence on the process of development, but there is a kind of connection between them that is influenced by the institutions, and this connection changes with the institutional changes.
Keywords
Acemoglu. D & J.A. Robinson. (2014). Why Nations Fail. Translated into Persian by M.mirdamadi & M Naeimipour. Rozaneh Publication. [in Persian]
Alamdari. K. (2000). Why Iran Lagged Behind and the West Moved Forward. Tehran: Tosee publications. [in Persian]
Almond. & B. Powell. (1966). Comparative Politics: Developmental Approach, Cambridge University Press
Anbari. M. (2015). Sociological evaluation of “Iranian Despotism” theory for studying historical development of Iran. Sociological Review. V2. N1: 51-76. [in Persian]
Aubin. E. (1983). Persia today. Translated into Persian by Ali Asghar saeedi. Tehran: Zavar Publication. [in Persian]
Azad Armaki. T. (2012). Intellectual foundations of Iranian society theory. Tehran: Elm Publication. [in Persian]
Bashiriyeh.H. (2003). Obstacles to political development in Iran. Tehran: Gham-e-Noo publication. [in Persian]
Bourdieu. P. (1998). Practical Reason: On the Theory of Action. Translated by Randal Johnson. Stanford University Press.
Chalabi. M. (1996). Sociology of order. Tehran: Ney publication. [in Persian]
Dieulafoy.J. (1953). Dieulafoy 's travelogue. Translated into Persian by H.Farehvashi. Tehran: Khayam publications(Bookstore). [in Persian]
Eisenstadt. S. (1973). Traditional Patrimonialism and Modern Neopatrimonialism. NewYork: Sage Publications.
Escobar. A. (1995). Encountering Development: The Making and Unmaking of the Third World ,Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Fakouhi. N. (2021). Anthropology of everyday injuries (10): nepotism. Nasser Fakuhi's website (https://nasserfakouhi.com). [in Persian]
Farasatkhah. M. (2021). We, Iranians. Tehran: Ney publications. [in Persian]
Farhadi. M. (2014). Industry against Tradition: Pathology of the Development Trend in Iran. semiannul journal of Indigenous knowledge, V1. N1:71-131. [in Persian]
Fazeli. M. (2021). Iran on a razor's edge. Tehran: Rozaneh publications. [in Persian]
Floor. W. (1988). social history of Iran in the Qajar era. V1. Translated into Persian by A. Serri. Tehran: Tous publications. [in Persian]
Foran. J. (1999). Fragile Resistance: Social Transformation in Iran From 1500 to the Revolution. Translated into Persian by A.Tadayon. Tehran: Rasa publications. [in Persian]
Ghazi Moradi. M. (2012). Dictatorship in Iran. Tehran: Ketab_e_Ameh publications. [in Persian]
Gobineau. J. (1977). Three years in Asia. Translated into Persian by Z.Mansouri. Tehran: Farrokhi Press Institute. [in Persian]
Gundel. J. K. Hedberg. N. & Zacharski. R. (1993). Cognitive status and the form of referring expressions. Language. 69:274–307.
Hedberg. Nancy. (2013). Applying the Givenness Hierarchy Framework: Methodological Issues. Simon Fraser University. Access in https://www.sfu.ca/~hedberg/Hedberg_Japan_paper_revised.pdf
Heiko. S. (2021). Germanic people from the point of view of archeology. Berlin: de Gruyter publications. [in German]
Jackson.W. (1978). Jackson's travelogue: Iran in the past and present. Translated into Persian by M.Amiri & F.badreie. Tehran. Kharazmi publication. [in Persian]
Jamalzadeh. M.A. (1966). The morality of us Iranians. Tehran: Iranian issues magazine publications. [in Persian]
Javadi Yeganeh. M.R. (2015). negative morality of Iranians; National character or social status. In G.R. Ghafari & M.R Javadi Yeganeh. A collection of articles on the country's social status report. V1. Tehran: The Social Council of the country and the Research Institute of Cultural and Social Studies: 261-322. [in Persian]
Kaempfer. E. (1985). Kaempfer 's travelogue. Translated into Persian by K. Jahandari. Tehran: Kharazmi publications. [in Persian]
Katouzian. H. (2012). he Persians: Ancient, Mediaeval and Modern Iran, Translated into Persian by H. Shahidi. Tehran: Markaz Publications. [in Persian]
Khalili. Mohsen. (2006). Critique of Englanders other Iranology. Political science research. 2: 166-138. [in Persian]
Kotobi. M. (1999). The place of lies and its behavioral patterns in our social relationships. Journal of Social science letter. 12: 137-156. [in Persian]
Landor. A.H.S. (2010). In the Forbidden Land. Translated into Persian by A.A. Rashidi. Tehran: Etelaat publications. [in Persian]
Lerner. D. (2002). The Passing of Traditional Society: Modernizing the Middle Eas, Translated into Persian by G.Khajesarvi. Tehran: Research Institute of Strategic Studies publications. [in Persian]
Malcolm. J. (1867). History of Iran. Translated into Persian by Mirza heyrat. Lithograph of India. [in Persian]
Mardiha. M. (2019). Temperament Genre: An Explanatory View. Quarterly Journal of Social Studies and Research in Iran. V8. N2: 257-278. [in Persian]
Mirzaei. H. & J.Rahmani. (2008). Iranians Culture and Personality in Foreign Itinerary. Journal of Iranian Cultural Research.3: 55-77. [in Persian]
Nabavi. N. (2021). Intellectuals and the state in Iran. Translated into Persian by Hasan Fesharaki. Tehran: shiraze publications. [in Persian]
Namdar. M. & J.Nazarimoghaddam. (2019). Validation of the Ttheory of "Oriental Ddespotism" in Uunderstanding Ssocial Ddevelopments in Iran. Critical Studies in Texts and Programs of Human Sciences. 64: 207-230. [in Persian]
Nazarimaghaddam. J & S.H. mousavi. (2019). A Reflection on the “Tyranny-centric Disposition of Iranians” Theory Based on Folk Literature with a Look at Tales of Gallantry and Trade. Social sciences. 85: 1-33. [in Persian]
Nizam al-Mulk. (2005). Siyasatnama. Tehran: Amirkabir publications. [in Persian]
North. D. (1999). Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance, Translated into Persian by M.Moeini.Tehran: the Program and Budget Organization Publications. [in Persian]
Palmer. R. (2013). A History of the Modern World .McGraw-Hill.
Paron. A. (2021). The Pechenegs: Nomads in the Political and Cultural Landscape of Medieval Europe, Translated by T. Anessi Leiden. Boston: Brill.
Polak.J.E. (1989). Iran and Iranians. Translated into Persian by K.Jahandari. Tehran: Kharazmi publication. [in Persian]
Pye.L & S. Verba. (1965). political culture and political development. prinston: prinston university press.
Rezagholi. A. (1998). Sociology of Killing of Elite, Tehran: Ney Publishing. [in Persian]
Rezaei. A.A & S.R. salehi & A.A.Rafieinejad. (2011). Cultural barriers in the political development in Iran and management strategy in this area. Journal of cultural management. 11: 15-32. [in Persian]
Saïd. E. (1978). Orientalism. new York: Pantheon Books.
Saltykov. A. (1957). Travel to Iran. Translated into Persian by M.Saba. Tehran: Book translation and publishing company. [in Persian]
Sariolghalam. M. (2007). Iran's political culture. Tehran: Research Institute of Cultural and Social Studies of the Ministry of Science. [in Persian]
Savage Landor. A.H. (2013). Across Coveted Lands. Translated into Persian by A.A. Abdorashdi, Tehran: Etelaat publishing company. [in Persian]
Savory. R. (1996). Iran Under the Safavids. Translated into Persian by K. Azizi. Tehran. Markaz publications. [in Persian]
Shamsoddini. A. (2011). General Election and Tribalism With Focus on Election Process of Fiveth to Eighjt Assembly of Islamic Council in Election Domain of Mamassani. Journal of law and politics. 14: 11-40. [in Persian]
Tabatabaei. S.J. (2002). On Iran: An Introduction to the Theory of Decline of Iran.Tehran: Negahemoaser publications. [in Persian]
Watson. G. (1978). History of Qajar era Iran. Translated into Persian by V.Mazandarani. Tehran: Amirkabir Publications. [in Persian]
Wills, C.J. (2010). The Land of the lion and the sun, or, modern Persia. Translated into Persian by G. Gharegozlou. Tehran: Eghbal Publications. [in Persian]
Zibakalam. S. (2000). How Did We Become What We Are?. Tehran: Rozaneh publications. [in Persian]
Zonis.M. (2008). Political Elites and Political Cynicism in Iran. Translated into Persian by P.Salehi. Tehran:
Chapakhsh publications. [in Persian]
استناد به این مقاله: حسینی داورانی، سیدعباس. (1401). بازشناسی «خلقیات ایرانی» در میدان «توسعه و عقبماندگی»، فصلنامه علوم اجتماعی، 29(96)، 203-242.
DOI: 10.22054/qjss.2023.70068.2566
Social sciences is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License...
)